Consensus
Wed 25 Sep 2024 1:04AM

consensus check on renaming "decision-makers" to "stewards"

AB Alyaza Birze Public Seen by 25

AB

Poll Created Wed 25 Sep 2024 1:02AM

checking for consensus on renaming "decision-makers" to "stewards" Closed Tue 1 Oct 2024 6:00AM

I'm checking for consensus on the following idea:

renaming "decision-makers" to "stewards"

as brought up in the discord by @walking mirage and @wenchcoat system (and maybe others), "decision-making group" is clunky, awkward, and just kind of not a good fit. the discord has talked over a few ideas for what should replace it and the people in those conversations collectively think stewards is a pretty good replacement.

as i personally put it in the discord:

it sort of fits the idea that this isn't above everything (because anyone can be a steward for something), and that we're not the final say of everything (because steward sounds a lot softer than like "administrator" or "decision-maker"--you steward a landscape but that doesn't mean you control it)

if you feel there's a better word for us though (or complications/implications with stewards we might want to consider before committing to it), we'd love to hear it.


@sirocyl has also suggested we give the name "custodian" to people holding specific tasks/roles within the proposed stewardship.

i'm opting to consolidate that suggestion into this proposal because it seems a bit much to separately vote on that.

accordingly, if you feel there's a better word for this you may raise a complication for it below too. please do your best to specify if you have issues with one or both proposed words though, given this.

Results

Results Option % of points Voters
No objections 100.0% 24 V T A MJL M K V AS CC O E E TD WM E S M WS R K
Complication 0.0% 0  
Objection 0.0% 0  
Undecided 0% 8 E N A G S M I A

24 of 32 people have participated (75%)

AB

Alyaza Birze
<span class="translation_missing" title="translation missing: en.poll_proposal_options.no objections">No Objections</span>
Wed 25 Sep 2024 1:02AM

my rationale is provided in the body of this vote

WM

walking mirage
<span class="translation_missing" title="translation missing: en.poll_proposal_options.no objections">No Objections</span>
Wed 25 Sep 2024 1:02AM

no objections to Stewards. we should still consider whether we want a specific title for the body of stewards or just call ourselves the League Stewards

T

Tenna
<span class="translation_missing" title="translation missing: en.poll_proposal_options.no objections">No Objections</span>
Wed 25 Sep 2024 1:02AM

I do like the sound of steward far more than "decision-maker".

TD

the dragon
<span class="translation_missing" title="translation missing: en.poll_proposal_options.no objections">No Objections</span>
Wed 25 Sep 2024 1:02AM

i like stewards and custodians

S

sirocyl
<span class="translation_missing" title="translation missing: en.poll_proposal_options.no objections">No Objections</span>
Wed 25 Sep 2024 1:02AM

oh yeah quorum babey 🎉

A

atonal440
<span class="translation_missing" title="translation missing: en.poll_proposal_options.no objections">No Objections</span>
Wed 25 Sep 2024 1:02AM

I think this is good: I like Custodian as a role title a lot, stewards as a group identity a little less but it does seem appropriate.